Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds has said the defence budget does include spending on the security and intelligence services but denied that the government was breaching NATO rules by doing so.
He was responding to a claim from former defence secretary Sir Ben Wallace that the government is creating a false impression that the UK is on course to meet its NATO commitments.
Asked if ministers were misleading the public, Reynolds told GB News: “So, very clearly, the answer is no on that. It’s a little bit rich of Mr Wallace to say that.
“I think his own quote on his own government he served in was that they hollowed out the armed forces. These definitions are international. There’s nothing specific to the UK about this. But the idea that we wouldn’t include the incredible work of our intelligence services, security services, given the nature of modern threats to the UK, I’m afraid I have no time for this argument at all.
“These definitions are consistent and international. There’s a definition of national security spend and military spend, but I’m afraid – look, the idea, knowing what they do, that we wouldn’t count money put into our intelligence services as part of our security and defensive spending, I think that’s absurd, knowing what they do, but knowing the nature of the threat. So I’m afraid there’s nothing in it.
“I think what, respectfully, Mr Wallace should focus on is, whichever definition you are using, there is more money going into it under this government than the plans that we inherited, and there’ll be more announcements on this in future.
“But I find it so rich that the people who, in their own words, hollowed out the British armed forces at a time of war in Europe, have something to say about this government, which has put more money into both and is continuing to do so, which is exactly what this country needs.”
He also denied that the government was seeking a deal on freedom of movement with the EU: “No. I can clarify that for you. So, what the government is negotiating with the European Union is the subject matter of our commitments, of our manifesto for the summit next month.
“That’s how food and agricultural products can move more easily between ourselves and Europe. Electricity trading, emissions, some of the complex things that matter quite a lot to industry. The longer term of that is the Prime Minister has said he wants to set out a relationship with Europe that removes uncertainty, that gets through some of the problems I have to deal with day to day in terms of our trading relationship with Europe.
“But he has got – no prior decisions [have been] made on that, no assumptions or decisions as to what that will be. He wants to set that out for the British public, and they’ll be the boss as to what the long-term relationship is going forward. So that’s not part of the here and now negotiations. It’s for the future.”
He added: “There are things on the European side that are steel tariffs and rules of origin on vehicles being made in the UK, he wants to set that up in a way where we’re taking out uncertainty from there. Now, one of the requests from the European side for that is about how we react to you know some of their rules on their side, and freedom of movement is a part of that.
“He is merely going to set out what the options are, and no decisions have been made. But on the impact on people, look, it’s complex. It has benefits. It has weaknesses in terms of what people really wanted from this in the referendum.
“I think in my area they wanted lower immigration overall. They obviously didn’t get that. Immigration tripled after Brexit had happened. The control of immigration has come from this Labour government, both illegal and legal. The numbers have come down substantially.
“So I think that’s an important part of the discussion as well, but this is about not the short term, but the long term. How are we going to take out uncertainty from our relationship with the EU? The Prime Minister will set that out in a speech after the UK-EU summit, but no decisions are made, and no assumptions should be given as to what that will actually take the form of.”
