Home Secretary’s new immigration plan is a ‘humiliating capitulation’ Conservatives claim

Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp has described Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reform plans as “a humiliating capitulation” to hard-left Labour MPs.

Philp told GB News: “Well, it’s a humiliating capitulation. Shabana Mahmood spent the last year pretending to be a tough Home Secretary, but under pressure from Angela Rayner and Labour’s open borders left, she has totally surrendered, and she has thrown in the bin her own plans that she announced just a few months ago by allowing hundreds of thousands of low-skilled, low-wage workers in the care sector to remain in the UK.

“All of them, she’s going to allow to remain in the UK. Most of them will end up getting the right to stay here permanently. They’ll get rights to have citizenship within a year, the rights to claim benefits, pensions, social housing, operations on the NHS, the whole lot.

“This cohort have brought with them hundreds of thousands of dependents. In fact, for every worker, there was more than one dependent brought into the country with them, and we know what this is going to cost because Shabana Mahmood herself published the estimate of the cost of this on March the fifth this year, and the answer is £10 billion.

“So, as your viewers are on their way to work this morning to work hard all day and pay their taxes, £10 billion of that money is going to end up subsidising benefits for people who came into the country.

“Oh, and to add insult to injury, Shabana Mahmood also admitted that many of those care workers entered the country fraudulently. Now, this is completely wrong. In my view, people who come into the country and either don’t work at all or work on low wages should, when their five-year temporary work visa expires, they should leave, and we should instead make welfare a lot tougher.

“So some of the 9 million economically inactive adults, which includes a million young people, instead get into work. That is much better than mass migration, mass low-skilled migration from outside Europe. It’s gone too far. It not only has to end, but it’s got to be reversed as well.”

On past Tory failures on immigration, he said: “I’ll be honest: there were some serious mistakes made in the past. Some things were got wrong. I’m going to be honest about that, and that is why, under new leadership, under Kemi Badenoch as the leader, me as shadow Home Secretary, we now have a very different approach.

“Firstly, being honest that some serious things were got wrong in the past. Secondly, making clear it’s not going to happen again because we’ll have very low migration caps in the future, much higher salary thresholds. We’re going to set that out in the future, but it’ll be a lot, lot lower than it is now to end mass migration.

“But thirdly, there is a way of reversing this, which is to say that people who are here on temporary work visas, on low wages, or not working at all should leave. There is a way of reversing this, and we think the government now should be doing that. It appears they’re not, so we are going to be tabling amendments to the bill going through Parliament to make that reversal happen.

“We can reverse this, and we should reverse it because mass immigration went too far. It was completely wrong. It needs to be stopped and also reversed. So we have changed a lot as a party because I recognise the serious mistakes made in the past. I’m not going to hide from that.”