The body representing the environmental health profession has responded to an opinion article published in the i Paper headlined ‘Britain’s pubs and clubs are dying – thanks to this obscure anti-noise crusader’.
The article argues that noise legislation, particularly the Environmental Protection Act 1990, has shifted too much power towards complainants and is contributing to the decline of pubs, clubs and other established venues and also references the impact of John Connell, who helped lobby for what became the 1960 Noise Abatement Act.
It suggests that complaints can be used to restrict businesses that bring life and character to our towns and cities, sometimes by people who have moved close to long-standing venues.
The Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (CIEH) recognises the immense cultural, social and economic value of Britain’s hospitality and night-time economy. However, presenting noise regulation as a battle between public enjoyment and “killjoy” complainants risks overlooking both the serious health effects of persistent noise and the careful, evidence-based work undertaken by local authority Environmental Health Officers (EHOs).
Somayya Yaqub, Chair of the Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (CIEH) Noise Advisory Panel, said:
“Nobody benefits from framing this as a choice between thriving pubs, clubs and music venues on the one hand, and protecting people from harmful noise on the other. Environmental health professionals work every day to support businesses, residents and communities to find practical solutions that allow venues to operate successfully while safeguarding people’s health and wellbeing.
“The Environmental Protection Act 1990 remains an essential piece of public health legislation. It does not give individuals the power to shut down businesses simply because they have made a complaint. Instead, it places a duty on local authorities to investigate concerns and take proportionate action where there is evidence that noise is causing a statutory nuisance or harming people’s quality of life.
“Our recently released Sound Thinking report found that nearly a quarter of people in England and Wales report being regularly disturbed by noise, while lower-income communities are disproportionately affected, which is contrary to what is suggested in this article.
“The report revealed that more than 305,000 noise complaints were recorded across England and Wales between 1 October 2024 and 30 September 2025. Yet councils issued only 2,282 abatement notices, a 72% fall over 20 years, while 190 prosecutions were lodged, representing a 71% reduction over the same period. These figures do not support the suggestion that environmental health teams are routinely reaching straight for punitive enforcement. Instead, they demonstrate that formal action is used in only a small minority of cases.
“The vast majority of noise complaints never result in formal enforcement action. Environmental health professionals want to work with venue operators, landlords and local communities to prevent problems arising and to help businesses meet their legal obligations. A vibrant hospitality sector and effective public health protection are not competing objectives.
“Rather than weakening protections that help safeguard communities from genuine harm, we should focus on better planning decisions, improved building standards and ensuring environmental health services are properly resourced to support both residents and businesses.”
CIEH’s Sound Thinking report combines analysis of local authority noise complaint data with new Ipsos polling of more than 2,100 adults aged 16-75 in England and Wales. It highlights the health impacts of environmental noise, identifies emerging sources of noise nuisance and sets out a series of policy recommendations aimed at improving how noise complaints are recorded, monitored and addressed.
